The Wife is tutoring a young student in her introductory drafting course. The professor has given explicit instructions to not use a straight-edge, compass, or any other tool.
All work must be done freehand.
Can someone explain the rationale behind that to me?
(The Wife thinks it would be easier to help, if she understood the restriction... but I don't get it either)
I can't speak to the instructor's thinking, but I recall having "no tool" drills in the "drafting and design" side of woodworking which were intended to develop a) blind contour drawing skills and b) "sketching fluency" - ie ability to quickly sketch fairly complex designs without being bogged down by tools.
Having said that this is the first concept The Wife is trying to help with. Perhaps it is a misunderstanding on the student's part.
I know some art and drafting instructors are obsessed with the idea you should be able to draw acceptably straight lines and balanced circles freehand, and be able to eyeball angles. Maybe that's all there is to it?
My drafting teacher back in the Pleistocene made us do blind contour drills every week and occasionally made us just draw circles on the board. He was old school, and didn't have any truck with that newfangled Euclid stuff.
Regarding "old school": I said to The Wife, "its not like 'being on the straight and level' is a new concept".
I'm hoping this is making a point in an assignment. As I understand it, the next assignment is do it in SketchUp.
I'm also a little dubious of teaching contradictory concepts in a single assignment (perspective and sketching at the same time?). But then again... I'm not a prof.
Also... I seem to remember from my TAing days... what the student thinks the prof said, and what the prof actually said, aren't always the same thing, that's why the student needs a tutor.